Local search explained

When someone searches for a plumber, a hairdresser or a café near them, Google builds a page from several different sources, each with its own rules. Understanding which part is which, and what decides who appears in each, saves a great deal of wasted effort. This guide explains the whole page in plain terms.

7 min readUpdated The team at Vantage Point Digital

Patchwork of bright green fields and hedgerows in the countryside
Contents
  1. What a local search results page is made of
  2. The map results: relevance, distance, prominence
  3. Service-area businesses
  4. The ordinary results: pages, not businesses
  5. Why directories and lead sites appear so often
  6. Area pages: helpful, or a risk?
  7. The AI summary at the top
  8. What you can and cannot influence
  9. A note on "rank tracking"
  10. Where to go from here
  11. Questions people ask

What a local search results page is made of

Search "electrician near me" or "dog groomer Harrogate" on a phone and scroll slowly. The page is usually built from these parts, in roughly this order:

  1. Ads. Marked "Sponsored". These can be ordinary Google Ads, or Local Services Ads with a "Google Guaranteed" or "Google Screened" badge where those are available for that trade.
  2. An AI summary. For some searches Google now shows an AI-written overview near the top, which may name businesses or link to sources.
  3. The map results. A map with, usually, three businesses listed under it. SEO people often call this the "local pack" or "map pack". Tapping "More places" opens the full list in Maps.
  4. The ordinary results. The familiar list of websites, sometimes called organic results. For local searches these often include directories and lead sites as well as businesses' own websites.

Each of these is decided differently. Effort on one does not automatically move another, which is why it helps to know which one you are trying to win.

The map results: relevance, distance, prominence

Google's own help pages say that local results are based mainly on three things.

Relevance is how well a Business Profile matches what someone searched for. Your primary category, secondary categories, services, description and the words in your reviews all feed into this. A profile categorised as "Plumber" with services listed for boiler repair, bathroom installation and leak detection is more relevant to those searches than one that just says "Plumbing and heating".

Distance is how far each business is from the searcher's location, or from the place named in the search. You cannot change this, and it is the reason a business ten minutes away may outrank you on a phone held in their street but not in yours. It is also why "ranking first" is not a single fact: you might be top for searches made near your base and nowhere for searches made twenty miles away.

Prominence is how well known a business is. Google mentions reviews (count and score), and information it has about the business from across the web, such as links, articles and directories. It also says that a website's position in the ordinary results contributes to prominence. That is one reason a good website helps your map ranking too.

Our Google Business Profile guide covers everything you can do to improve relevance, and our reviews guide covers the biggest part of prominence.

Service-area businesses

If you travel to customers rather than having them visit you, Google treats you as a service-area business. You hide your address on your profile and list the areas you serve instead, up to 20 of them, which Google advises should not stretch much beyond about two hours' drive from your base.

Two things are worth knowing. First, Google still knows where you are based even when the address is hidden, and distance from that base still influences where you appear. Listing a town forty miles away as a service area tells customers you will go there, but it will not make you rank there against businesses based in it. Second, this is normal and fair: someone searching in that town is usually better served by a business nearby. Your best chance in distant towns is the ordinary results, with genuinely useful pages, not the map.

The ordinary results: pages, not businesses

Below the map are web pages. Google ranks each page on how well it answers the search, how trustworthy and useful it is, how well the site works, especially on a phone, and many other signals. The important thing for a small business is that Google is ranking pages. If you have one page about everything, it is competing with other businesses' dedicated pages about the exact thing searched for, and it will usually lose.

That is why our trade website checklist recommends a page for each main service. A page about "loft conversions in Reading" with photos of your loft conversions, honest answers to common questions and a price guide is far more likely to rank for that search than a home page that mentions lofts in a list.

Why directories and lead sites appear so often

For many local searches the ordinary results are full of Checkatrade, Yell, MyBuilder, Bark and similar sites. They rank because they are large, well-linked sites with a page for almost every trade and town combination. You can compete with them by being listed on them, which also helps prominence, and by having better, more specific pages yourself. They rarely have real photos of a specific job in your town, and you do.

Misty mountains over calm water at dusk in the Highlands

Area pages: helpful, or a risk?

It is tempting to build a page for every town and village you cover. Done badly, this is exactly what Google's spam policies describe as doorway pages: many pages created to rank for similar searches that funnel users to the same place, with little unique value. Google says sites that do this can be demoted, and in serious cases the whole site can lose ranking.

An area page is worth creating when it is genuinely useful to someone in that area: jobs you have done there with photos, local considerations such as conservation areas, typical property types, parking or access issues, and how quickly you can get there. If you cannot write something specific and true about a place, list it on your areas page instead. A short, honest list does you no harm. A hundred thin town pages can.

The AI summary at the top

Google's AI Overviews, and AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot, increasingly answer questions like "who is a good roofer near me" directly. They draw on websites, reviews, Business Profiles and what other sites say about a business. The things that help you appear in them are largely the same things that help everywhere else: a complete profile, consistent details across the web, real reviews, and a website that clearly says what you do and where. Our guide to being recommended by AI search goes into the detail, and our page on AI search explains what every site we build does for it.

What you can and cannot influence

FactorCan you influence it?How
DistanceBarelyOnly by where you are genuinely based
Profile relevanceYesCategories, services, description, photos
ReviewsYesAsk every customer, reply to every review
Consistency across the webYesSame name, phone and address everywhere
Website qualityYesClear pages per service, fast on a phone
Mentions and linksPartlyTrade bodies, local press, suppliers, community
Searcher's locationNoNobody controls this

A note on "rank tracking"

Because distance matters so much, the same search gives different results in different streets. Tools that report "you rank third for plumber in Leeds" are showing one point on a map. Some tools check from a grid of locations, which gives a truer picture. Simpler still: ask new customers how they found you, and watch the calls and website clicks figures on your Business Profile.

Where to go from here

If you want to know how you appear in a real search for your trade and area, our free Business MOT runs one and shows you who is above you and why. For the practical steps, start with our guide to getting more work from Google.

Questions people ask

What is the Google map pack?
It is the map with usually three businesses listed under it that appears for many local searches. The businesses come from Google Business Profiles and are ranked mainly on relevance, distance and prominence.
Why do I show up on Google Maps in some places but not others?
Distance from the searcher is one of the main ranking factors for local results. You are likely to appear near your base and less often further away, even within your listed service areas.
Does my website affect my Google Maps ranking?
Yes, indirectly. Google says that a business's position in ordinary web results contributes to its prominence, which is one of the factors in local ranking.
Should I make a page for every town I cover?
Only where you have something specific and useful to say about that town. Near-identical town pages are treated as doorway pages under Google's spam policies and can harm the whole site.

Who wrote this

The team at Vantage Point Digital. Built by a team with 35 years in marketing, design and print, leading studios and building brands. We build websites and the software behind them for UK trades and local businesses, and we write these guides so the advice is free whether or not you ever work with us.

Rules and schemes change. We check these guides and update them; where a rule matters, follow the official source we name.

Free Business MOT

See where you stand, free.

A real Google search for your trade and area, your Google Business Profile and reviews, and your website loaded on a phone. About a minute, no card, and a plain answer on what is worth fixing first.

Run the free MOT